-
I would have been born 10 years earlier.
-
Well, so Nagel's wrong in saying it's not possible
-
to imagine being born earlier.
-
In at least some cases, it is.
-
Yet, if we imagine somebody like this,
-
somebody who's an offspring of this kind of fertility clinic,
-
and we ask, would they be upset
-
that they weren't born earlier?
-
again, it still seems as though most people would say,
-
"No, of course not."
-
So the Nagel answer doesn't seem
-
to me to be an adequate one.