-
how many coins do I think is in this jar, that's the naive thing.
-
The relevant estimate is:
-
how many coins do I think is in this jar
-
given my shaking of it and given the fact
-
that I have won the auction,
-
given the supposition that I might win the auction.
-
So the relevant estimate when bidding is
-
how many coins do I think are there given my initial guess,
-
Yi, and given that Yi is bigger than Yj.
-
Now, notice this is kind of a weird thing.
-
It's a counter factual thing.
-
I don't know at the time at which I'm bidding,