来自《耶鲁大学开放课程—哲学：死亡 第6集 第6集》

• 
  
  and the Morning Star does not.
  而晨星不存在
• 
  
  And so we've got a--we could imagine then a--
  所以我们得到一个 我们可以想象一个
• 
  
  Descartes-like argument saying,
  笛卡尔式的论证
• 
  
  "If I can imagine the Evening Star without the Morning Star,
  如果我能想象昏星存在而晨星不存在
• 
  
  that shows the Evening Star
  这就证明了昏星
• 
  
  and the Morning Star must be two different heavenly bodies."
  和晨星肯定是两个不同的天体
• 
  
  But in fact, that's not so.
  事实并非如此
• 
  
  The Evening Star and the Morning Star
  昏星和晨星
• 
  
  are the very same heavenly body.
  是同一个天体
• 
  
  In fact, it's not a star at all.
  实际上它根本不是恒星
• 
  
  It's a planet. It's Venus, if I recall correctly.
  它只是颗行星 金星 我没记错的话
• 
  
  So look, there's only one thing.
  看啊 这里只有一个东西