来自《耶鲁大学开放课程—哲学：死亡 第6集 第6集》
-
where exactly did it go wrong?到底是哪里出了问题 -
Look, take the argument of the planets,拿行星的论证 -
the Morning Star and the Evening Star example.晨星和昏星的那个例子来说 -
I take it that we all agree我想大家都同意 -
that when we attempt to run the Cartesian argument当我们试图把卡氏论证 -
in terms of the Morning Star and the Evening Star,用到晨星和昏星的例子上来时 -
it fails. But it's harder to say what went wrong?它行不通了 但是很难说我们哪里错了 -
How did it go wrong? Why did it go wrong?它怎么会出错的 为什么会出错 -
What are the possibilities?有哪些可能性 -
Well, we said, look, first claim, first premise.第一个要求 第一个前提 -
I can imagine a world in which the Evening Star exists,我可以想象一个昏星存在 -
but the Morning Star doesn't.而晨星不存在的世界