-
at least over the last century and a half,
-
you have to ask yourself: is this the reading that Plato intended?
-
Did Plato want us to read the dialogue this way?
-
As a teacher of mine used to say, "You read Plato your way, I'll read
-
him his way."
-
But, how did Plato intend this dialogue to be understood?
-
Note that Socrates never defends himself by reference to the doctrine
-
of unlimited free speech.
-
He doesn't make that claim.
-
He doesn't make the claim about the general utility of freedom
-
or unlimited speech.
-
Rather, he maintains as he puts it near the end of the defense speech,