-
Yeah, it would be a problem for believing in souls
-
if Righty could wake up without one.
-
But since we stipulated that
-
Shelly Kagan's soul is going to end up in Lefty,
-
Righty is not going to wake up.
-
Alternatively, it might have been that Righty woke up,
-
but Lefty doesn't wake up,
-
doesn't survive the operation.
-
Suppose we did these sort of brain transfers all the time
-
and the following thing always happened.
-
Transfer the entire brain, the patient wakes up.
-
Transfer one hemisphere, the patient wakes up.