来自《耶鲁大学开放课程—哲学：死亡 第7集 第7集》

• 
  
  that the soul is one of the recycled parts.
  灵魂就是一个循环的部件
• 
  
  So it seems to me "The argument from recycling,"
  在我看来循环观点
• 
  
  as I call it, is not successful either.
  也是不成功的
• 
  
  Now, as I say, many times when you read the dialogue,
  很多时候当你阅读柏拉图的对话录
• 
  
  this or other dialogues by Plato,
  不管是这篇还是其他篇
• 
  
  it seems as though he's fully cognizant of the objections
  柏拉图似乎很清楚至少有一个留心的读者
• 
  
  that at least an attentive reader will raise
  会对早期的一些观点
• 
  
  about earlier stages of the argument.
  提出反驳意见
• 
  
  Because sometimes the best way to
  因为有些时候
• 
  
  understand a later argument is to see it as responding
  理解后期观点最好的办法
• 
  
  to the weaknesses of earlier arguments.
  是看它如何回应早期观点的缺陷与不完善
• 
  
  And I think that's pretty clearly
  我想这就很清楚的