-
They never, strictly speaking, died at all."
-
So what?
-
They were on the border looking in.
-
To suggest that that couldn't be relevant evidence
-
is like saying I can't tell you anything interesting about
-
what's going on in the hallway right now,
-
because after all I'm not in the hallway;
-
I'm here in the lecture hall.
-
So what?
-
Even though I'm here in the lecture hall,
-
I can see into the hallway and tell you what's going on in it.
-
So attempts to dismiss the appeal to near-